When California's Proposition 8 (Prop. 8) eliminated the right to matTy a person of the same sex, it aggravated a fissure between the black community and the gay community. Though Prop. 8 had nothing to do with race on the surface, the controversy that followed its passage was charged with racial blame. This Article uses the Prop. 8 controversy, including the ensuing Perry litigation challenging the law, as a window into relations between the black and gay communities. Although the matTiage equality movement bills itself as a descendant of the black civil rights movement, it often treats its forefather as dead: The political rhetoric and legal arguments of the gay rights movement routinely embrace postracialism, the notion that American society has moved beyond racial difference and hierarchy. Such arguments imply that the struggle for racial justice is over, with g,-ays supplanting blacks as the paradigmatic stigmatized minority. In the words of 1he Advocate, a leading Lesbian Gay Bisexual T ransgender (LG BT) periodical, "Gay Is the New Black."

This is the first Article to identify the postracial narratives at the heart of matTiage equality argumentation-in the media, on the streets, and in the courts. I show that such claims reflect an oppression Olympics, undermine black-gay relations, and are not dictated by constitutional precedent. Moreover, such claims may inadvertently constrict equality for both groups, marking the end of civil rights for both the black and LGBT communities. I urge the matTiage equality movement to attend to race carefully, taking account of the history of the Supreme Court's application of strict scrutiny to race and the ongoing subordination affiicting the black community decades after securing formal equality. This analysis casts doubt on whether the LGBT community should aspire to be "the new black." Attending to the trajectory ofblack claims for civil rights could lead matTiage equality advocates to create doctrinal space for remedial efforts necessary to transform formal equality into equality in fact.

Included in

Law Commons



To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.